Accepted One Offer, Now I Have a Better One—What Should I Do?
Hey everyone! I just received an offer from Liberty Mutual, which I’ve been aiming for. However, I had already accepted a position with a smaller, well-established company that boasts a solid AM Best rating and is experiencing rapid growth. The pay is quite different—$27/hr at Liberty Mutual compared to $20/hr with the smaller company.
On top of that, the smaller company has been incredibly supportive, even covering my transportation costs, and I have great respect for the manager I would be working with there. Both jobs are set to start on the same day (though Liberty Mutual is open to a delayed start), and both positions are hybrid.
I’m feeling torn about this decision. I truly don’t want to back out of an opportunity that I was genuinely excited about—especially since they’ve already invested resources into me. I’d hate for them to see my announcement about Liberty Mutual later on. I could really use some advice on how to navigate this situation!
It sounds like you’re in a pretty tough position, and it’s understandable to feel conflicted about this decision. Here are a few points to consider that might help you navigate your choice:
Evaluate Your Priorities: Reflect on what matters most to you in your career right now. Is it the salary, the company culture, the specific role, or the potential for growth? Make a list and see which offer aligns best with your goals.
The Impact of Backing Out: Consider the potential consequences of withdrawing from the smaller company. They invested time and resources in you, and pulling out may affect your reputation. Think about how this might impact future opportunities and whether it’s worth that risk.
Growth Potential: While the pay at Liberty Mutual is higher, weigh that against the growth potential and opportunities for advancement at both companies. If the smaller company is on a rapid growth trajectory, you may find better opportunities there in the long run, which could close the pay gap sooner than you think.
Delayed Start Opportunity: If Liberty Mutual allows a delayed start, could you discuss that option with the smaller company? It might give you more time to transition without burning bridges.
Gut Feeling: Sometimes, your instincts are the best guide. Think about where you see yourself being happier and more fulfilled.
Ultimately, there isn’t a right or wrong decision here. Trust yourself to make a choice that aligns with your values and career aspirations. If you do decide to go with Liberty Mutual, it may be worth communicating openly with the smaller company about your decision and expressing your gratitude for their support. Good luck!