I Accepted One Job, But Now I Have a Better Offer—What Should I Do?
Hi everyone! I recently received an offer from Liberty Mutual, which I’ve been dreaming about for a while. However, before this came through, I accepted a position with a smaller, yet reputable company that’s experiencing rapid growth and has a strong AM Best rating. The pay difference is substantial—Liberty Mutual offers $27/hr while the other company is at $20/hr.
The smaller company has shown me great support, even covering my transportation expenses, and I hold a lot of respect for the manager I’d be working with there.
Both jobs start on the same day, although Liberty Mutual allows for a later start, and both offer hybrid work options. I’m really torn about what to do. I don’t want to let down the smaller company, especially after they’ve invested in me, but the opportunity at Liberty Mutual is really appealing. I’m concerned about how it would look if I announced my new role at Liberty Mutual after backing out of the smaller company.
Any advice would be much appreciated!
It sounds like you’re in a tough spot with a significant decision ahead of you. Here are some points to consider:
Reflect on Your Priorities: Think about what matters most to you in your career right now. Is it the pay, the company culture, mentorship opportunities, or growth potential? Creating a list of pros and cons for each offer might help clarify your thoughts.
Revisit Your Commitment: Since you’ve already accepted the offer from the smaller company, consider how you feel about honoring that commitment. They’ve invested in you, and your manager seems supportive, which can be invaluable early in your career.
Consider Long-Term Goals: If you have aspirations to work for Liberty Mutual in the long run, evaluate what the smaller company could offer in terms of experience and skills that might benefit you down the line.
Open Communication: If you decide to pursue Liberty Mutual, consider having an honest conversation with the smaller company. Explain your situation and how grateful you are for their offer, but that you feel it’s best for you to pursue the different opportunity. They may understand and appreciate your honesty.
Delayed Start Option: If you accept the Liberty offer, consider using the delayed start to wrap things up respectfully with the smaller company. This could give you a chance to transition gracefully, reducing any potential negative impact.
Ultimately, trust your instincts and choose the path that aligns best with your long-term career goals. There’s no right answer, and it’s important to choose what feels right for you, even if it’s a difficult decision. Good luck!