Accepted One Offer, Now I’ve Got Another—What Should I Do?
Hey everyone! I just received an offer from Liberty Mutual, which is exciting. However, before I got this offer, I had already accepted a position with a smaller, yet well-established company that boasts a strong AM Best rating and is experiencing rapid growth. I’ve been keen to work at Liberty Mutual for some time, and the pay is significantly higher ($27/hr with Liberty vs. $20/hr with the smaller company). On the flip side, the smaller company has been incredibly supportive, even covering my transportation expenses, and I really admire the manager I would be working with.
Both jobs start on the same day (though Liberty allows for a delayed start), and both offer hybrid work options. I’m torn over this decision because I don’t want to back out of an opportunity I was genuinely excited about, especially since they’ve invested in me—leaving them to see my announcement about Liberty Mutual later could be awkward. I’d appreciate any advice on how to navigate this situation!
It’s definitely a tough situation, and it’s great that you’re considering the impact of your decision on both companies. Here are a few steps to think through as you navigate this:
Reflect on Your Long-Term Goals: Consider which position aligns better with your career aspirations. While Liberty Mutual might be a prestigious name, think about what you want in terms of growth opportunities, company culture, and work-life balance.
Evaluate the Support from the Smaller Company: The fact that the smaller company has already shown support by covering transportation costs speaks volumes about their commitment to you. If you admire your potential manager and feel a sense of loyalty, that’s an important factor to consider.
Consider Financial Implications: The pay difference is significant, so assess how much that $27/hr versus $20/hr will impact your lifestyle and financial goals. However, balance this with the potential opportunities for growth and advancement at each company.
Communication is Key: If you decide to go with Liberty Mutual, it’s important to communicate professionally and respectfully with the smaller firm. You can express your appreciation for their offer and explain that you’ve received an unexpected opportunity that aligns more closely with your career goals.
Delayed Start with Liberty: Since Liberty Mutual allows for a delayed start, it could be worthwhile to use this time to leverage your initial commitment to the smaller company and ease the transition, if that’s the route you choose.
Trust Your Gut: Ultimately, whichever direction you lean towards, trust your instincts. This decision is about your future, and you want to choose the place that excites you the most and will support you professionally.
Remember, it’s okay to change your mind, especially if you’ve weighed your options thoughtfully. Good luck with your decision!