Someone hit my car and their insurance says I’m 35% responsible.

Navigating Insurance Disputes After a Minor Accident: A Personal Experience

Encountering complications with insurance claims can be both frustrating and confusing. Recently, I found myself involved in a minor car incident that highlights some of the challenges drivers may face when dealing with insurance companies.

The Incident

While driving through a gas station parking lot at a very slow pace—approximately five miles per hour—a vehicle backing out of a parking space unexpectedly collided with my passenger side door. Fortunately, I was able to obtain surveillance footage from the gas station, which clearly indicates that I was not at fault during the incident. Despite this evidence, my insurance provider, State Farm, has assigned only a 65% responsibility to the other driver, leaving me with a 35% liability.

Insurance Dispute and Efforts to Resolve

I have spoken directly with a supervisor at State Farm to address the discrepancy, but my concerns remain unresolved. Given my full coverage, including collision insurance, I am now exploring my options for contesting this assessment and ensuring that my claim is handled fairly.

Key Takeaways

  • Always review the footage or any available evidence after an accident, no matter how minor.
  • Understand your insurance coverage, particularly collision and comprehensive protections.
  • Engage directly with your insurance company’s representatives and escalate your concerns if necessary.
  • Be aware that insurance responsibility determinations may sometimes differ from your perspective, and persistence can be critical in dispute resolution.

Moving Forward

In situations like these, understanding your rights and the nuances of insurance claims is essential. If you find yourself facing a similar challenge, gather all evidence, communicate clearly with your insurer, and seek advice or legal assistance if needed. Staying informed and proactive can make a significant difference in ensuring a fair outcome.


Note: This post is based on personal experience and should not be taken as professional legal advice. Always consult with a qualified insurance specialist or legal professional for specific guidance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *