Legal and Insurance Concerns After an Uninsured Trucking Incident
Encountering a road accident involving commercial trucks can be a complex and frustrating experience, especially when the trucking company involved appears to lack valid insurance coverage. Here’s a detailed overview of a recent incident and some critical considerations for those navigating similar situations.
Incident Overview
Recently, our vehicle was involved in a minor collision on the highway, caused when a trucker merged improperly across double solid lines into our lane, resulting in damages estimated at approximately $11,000. The truck driver provided their insurance details at the scene, and I documented the policy information with photographs.
Investigative Findings
Upon reaching out to the insurance provider, I was informed that the policy had been terminated two months prior to the accident. Efforts to contact the truck driver’s manager at the trucking firm have been unproductive—they request I call back when they are available and are currently avoiding further communication.
Further research on the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) website reveals that the company’s only active insurance policy is with Geico Marine, which raises suspicions. Industry insights suggest that some trucking companies may register temporary or non-commercial policies, such as marine insurance, to meet minimal legal requirements while avoiding comprehensive coverage for commercial operations—a potentially deceptive practice designed to circumvent insurance regulations.
Additionally, the company filed their MCS-150 form (the Safety and Fitness electronic record) just three days after the incident, which may indicate attempts to update or conceal their current insurance status.
Legal and Strategic Considerations
This situation prompts several critical questions:
-
Is the trucking company waiting out a statute of limitations or simply hoping the incident will be forgotten?
-
Should immediate legal action be pursued, such as consulting an attorney or sending a formal demand letter via certified mail?
-
Would filing a lawsuit be appropriate at this stage?
Given that the driver involved is a family member with comprehensive coverage—though he was operating for Uber at the time—there are additional layers of complexity. If the ride was during an Uber shift, the insurance coverage might differ or have specific exclusions. It’s important to determine whether the Uber insurance policy is active and applicable, and whether our own insurer would honor a claim made under such circumstances. Some insurance providers may refuse coverage if the accident occurred while the driver was engaged in commercial ride-sharing activities, which could lead to our policy being revoked or claims being denied.
Next Steps and Precautions
Considering these factors, it’s advisable to:
- Continue attempting
