Understanding Vehicle Damage in a Personal Driveway: Insurance and Liability Considerations
Introduction
Encountering a vehicle collision on private property, such as your own driveway, can be a perplexing and stressful situation. Many individuals wonder about the implications for insurance claims and liability—especially when an unoccupied vehicle is involved. If you ever find yourself in a similar circumstance, understanding the nuances can help you navigate the next steps more confidently.
Scenario Overview
Imagine living in a suburban Detroit area, where your trusted 2017 Ford Expedition is parked in the driveway. During this time, your fiancé’s 20-year-old son, driving his vintage 1974 Ford F100 truck—which is registered, insured, and part of a restoration project—enters the scene. The truck is positioned uphill from your vehicle; after parking, the young man steps out of the truck, closes the door, and inadvertently causes the truck to roll backward, colliding with your parked Expedition.
The aftermath reveals noticeable damages: a flat tire, dented bumper, broken headlight, and potential harm to aftermarket wheels, tires, and suspension components. Fortunately, the incident was captured on security cameras, confirming the vehicle was unoccupied at the moment of impact. While your Expedition’s repairs might be substantial, the damage to the truck appears minimal—mostly superficial scratches.
Insurance and Liability Considerations
One common question following such an incident revolves around fault and coverage:
-
Is the parked driver at fault even if they just exited the vehicle?
Generally, liability hinges on whether the person was responsible for the vehicle at the time of the incident. Even if the driver had recently exited, if the vehicle began to move without authorization or proper control, liability could be attributed to the driver—here, the young man. -
Would homeowners insurance cover the damages?
Homeowners policies typically do not cover damages caused by moving vehicles, especially those not classified as a “for-profit” activity. Unless the vehicle was parked in a manner that violated local ordinances or was involved in an explicit off-property activity, homeowners insurance might not respond. -
Could this be an auto insurance claim instead?
Since the vehicle involved is insured and registered, filing a claim through auto insurance could be appropriate. Given the damage to your Expedition and the insured status of the truck, your insurance may evaluate whether to pursue a claim against the young man’s policy or handle it directly if coverage permits.
Liability and Responsibility
In