Considering Dropping Collision and Comprehensive Coverage on Older Vehicles: What You Need to Know
As vehicle owners, evaluating insurance coverage options is a common part of vehicle management—especially as cars age. Recently, some owners have contemplated whether it’s worthwhile to maintain collision and comprehensive insurance on older models. If you’re in a similar situation, it’s important to understand the potential risks and benefits before making a decision.
Assessing Your Vehicles
In this scenario, two vehicles—both around 15 years old—are primarily used by family members. One is a Subaru Outback, and the other is a Mazda 3. These vehicles have served well over the years, and now, the question is whether paying for extensive coverage makes financial sense.
The Rationale Behind Dropping Full Coverage
Some vehicle owners consider eliminating collision and comprehensive insurance on older cars because these policies can become costly relative to the vehicle’s current value. The idea is: if the vehicles are nearing the end of their financial depreciation, the premiums paid might outweigh the potential benefits.
Potential Drawbacks
Before opting out of full coverage, consider the following:
-
Liability vs. Full Coverage: Basic liability insurance covers damages you cause to others but doesn’t protect your vehicle. Without comprehensive and collision coverage, you’ll bear the full cost of repairs if your car is damaged or stolen.
-
Damage in Accidents or Thefts: Although older cars may have lower market value, repair costs can still be significant, especially if the vehicle can’t be replaced easily. Insurance companies typically payout based on the actual cash value, which may be modest, but repairs and replacements can be costly.
-
Loan or Lease Agreements: If the vehicle is financed or leased, you are usually required to keep comprehensive and collision coverage until the loan is paid off.
Financial Considerations
In regions like California, insurance policies are subject to state regulations and market conditions. While some owners expect minimal payouts for damages on older vehicles, others find that comprehensive coverage offers peace of mind—especially against theft, vandalism, or natural disasters.
Final Thoughts
Deciding whether to drop collision and comprehensive insurance involves weighing the cost savings against potential out-of-pocket expenses in case of an accident or theft. If your vehicles are fully paid off, and their current market value is low, dropping full coverage may be a reasonable choice. However, carefully assess your risk tolerance and financial ability to handle unexpected damages.
Consult with your insurance provider for personalized advice—they
