Understanding Insurance Challenges with Multiple Claims and Property Ownership
Navigating Homeowners Insurance When You Have Multiple Claims in a Short Period
If you’ve ever faced difficulties securing homeowners insurance due to previous claims, you’re not alone. Recent experiences highlight the complexities insurers face when assessing risk, especially for homeowners with a history of multiple claims across different properties.
A Case in Point: Multiple Claims in a Short Time Frame
Consider a homeowner who, in August 2023, replaced their roof following a hailstorm in Texas. Interestingly, this was their first-ever insurance claim in 15 years of residence, and it pertained solely to that property. After relocating to Colorado, they purchased a new home with a roof more than a decade old and experienced a severe hailstorm, leading to another claim just last month. They’ve owned both homes for approximately two and a half years—selling the Texas property last year—and currently hold a policy with Connect Insurance.
However, during their recent policy review, they learned that their insurer was terminating their coverage due to what they described as “cracking down” on clients with multiple claims within a three-year span. Meanwhile, their premium has steadily increased over the past three years, jumping from $3,000 to over $4,300. Frustrated by the rising costs and limited options, they’re exploring whether alternative approaches could yield better outcomes.
Key Questions for Homeowners Facing Similar Situations
-
Does owning multiple properties influence insurance decisions regarding recent claims?
Insurers often consider the broader scope of property ownership, but how precisely this affects individual claim assessments varies among providers. It’s worth understanding if multiple policies can mitigate perceived risks or if they inadvertently flag a higher risk profile. -
Is it beneficial to seek quotes from other companies, or will I encounter the same response?
While some insurers might have strict policies, others may be more flexible. Consulting multiple providers or working with specialized agents could uncover options that better match your circumstances. -
Could engaging a private insurance broker be advantageous?
Independent insurance agents can offer tailored advice and access to a broader market of policies, potentially improving your chances of securing coverage, especially when traditional insurers decline coverage.
Final Thoughts
Homeowners with multiple claims, even if separated by years and properties, often face scrutiny from insurance companies aiming to manage risk. But understanding the nuances—such as the role of multiple policies and exploring different avenues—can help you find suitable coverage. If you
