Understanding Insurance Challenges for Multi-Property Owners: A Case Study
Navigating the world of homeowners insurance can be complex, especially for those with multiple properties. Recently, I encountered some noteworthy restrictions and policies that highlight the importance of understanding insurer criteria. Here’s a detailed look into a real-world scenario that might resonate with many property owners.
Background
In August 2023, I arranged for a roof replacement on my Texas home due to hail damage—a common issue in that area. Over the 15 years I lived there, this was the only insurance claim I ever filed for that property, making it my first and only claim across all my properties to date.
Subsequently, I relocated to Colorado. During the 2.5 years of owning both homes—renting out the Texas property before selling it last year—and managing a new claim for hail damage on the Colorado residence, I’ve experienced the typical insurance journey. My current provider is Connect, but I’ve become dissatisfied due to a significant premium increase over three years and the unwelcome decision to transfer my policy underwriting to Homesite.
The Challenge
While shopping for alternative quotes, I reached out to State Farm and was informed that they are tightening their policies regarding clients with multiple claims within a short period—specifically, claims made within three years. This raised several questions about how insurers evaluate multi-property ownership and claims history.
Key Questions
-
Does owning multiple homes and policies influence an insurer’s decision-making process? Should this factor mitigate concerns about recent claims?
-
Is it worthwhile to contact other insurance providers, or will I face the same restrictions elsewhere?
-
Would consulting a private insurance agent be beneficial? (I haven’t worked with one before but recently came across the option during research.)
Takeaways
For property owners managing multiple homes, understanding insurers’ policies on claims history is crucial. Multi-property ownership might not always shield you from perceived risks, especially when multiple claims occur within a short timeframe. Exploring options like independent agents could offer more personalized solutions tailored to your unique circumstances.
If you’re facing similar challenges, consider thoroughly reviewing your policy history, gathering multiple quotes, and consulting experienced professionals to navigate the evolving landscape of homeowners insurance effectively.
