Understanding Insurance Challenges When Owning Multiple Properties: A Case Study
Navigating the complexities of home insurance can be particularly challenging for property owners with multiple homes. Recently, I encountered some hurdles with my insurance providers that highlight important considerations for multi-property owners.
Background Context
In August 2023, I had to replace my roof in Texas due to hail damage—a claim I had never filed in my 15 years of residence there. This was the sole insurance claim I had ever made on that property or any other. After relocating to Colorado, I purchased a new home. The roof on this property is over 12 years old, and recently, it also sustained damage from large hailstones. Consequently, I filed a claim last month.
Current Insurance Situation
Initially, I was insured through Connect Insurance; however, I was unhappy with their decision to transfer my policy underwriting to Homesite and the significant premium hikes over the past few years—from around $3,000 to over $4,300 annually. While exploring other options, I reached out to State Farm, only to be informed that they are tightening policies for individuals with multiple claims within a three-year window.
Key Questions
This experience raises some important questions:
-
Should owning multiple properties influence how insurers assess my risk, given that I hold separate policies for each home?
-
Is it worthwhile to approach other insurance providers, or will they likely adopt the same stance regarding recent claims?
-
Would working with a private insurance agent provide a strategic advantage, perhaps offering more flexible options or better guidance?
Final Thoughts
For homeowners managing multiple properties, understanding how claims impact insurance eligibility and premiums is crucial. It’s advisable to clarify each insurer’s policies regarding multiple claims and consider consulting with independent agents who might offer more personalized solutions. Staying informed and proactive can help navigate the evolving landscape of property insurance more effectively.
For more insights on managing multiple insurance policies and optimizing coverage, stay tuned to our blog.
