Title: Navigating Rental Car Insurance Claims When Using Loyalty Points: A Cautionary Tale
Handling rental cars can be straightforward—until insurance disputes cloud the picture. Recently, a situation arose where a seemingly simple rental turned into a complicated insurance claim, highlighting some critical considerations for travelers utilizing loyalty points and premium credit cards.
The Scenario: Renting a Car with Loyalty Points and Minimal Payment
Imagine booking a vehicle entirely online through a major rental agency, such as Enterprise, and applying loyalty points to significantly reduce the rental fee. In this case, the driver was able to bring the payable amount down to just $5.47, which was settled using a premium credit card, specifically the Chase Sapphire Reserve (CSR). This card offers primary rental car coverage, provided certain conditions are met: the full rental charge must be billed to the card, and the renter must decline the rental company’s Collision Damage Waiver (CDW).
What Went Wrong? An Accident and an Insurance Claim
During the rental period, an unforeseen minor accident occurred. After returning the vehicle, the driver filed a claim with CSR’s insurance provider (Virginia Surety/Assurant). Despite having used the card’s benefits previously without issue, this time the insurer appeared to raise hurdles. The primary sticking point?
The insurer demanded a credit card billing statement displaying the full amount charged for the rental, which was only $5.47. Multiple submissions of the same statement, clearly indicating the total charge, seemingly had little effect. The insurer persisted in requesting additional proof, raising concerns about whether the claim was being denied due to the use of loyalty points to offset the rental fee.
Key Takeaways and Legal Considerations
-
Terms and Conditions Matter: The CSR’s benefits specify that to activate primary coverage, the full rental amount must be charged to the card. There’s no explicit mention that discounts or points used to reduce the cost negate this requirement.
-
The Full Payment Must Be Charged to the Card: Even if the rental fee is minimized through points, if the total charged on the card matches the rental amount, the primary coverage should typically apply.
-
In Practice: Disputes can arise if the insurance provider perceives the discounted amount as insufficient, or if they interpret the policy differently. Clear communication and documentation are essential.
-
What Can Renters Do?
- Always confirm the terms regarding points and discounts before booking.
- Save all documentation showing the total charged amount
