Title: Navigating Liability Disputes After a Multi-Car Accident: A Case Study
If you’ve ever found yourself in the aftermath of a car accident, you know how confusing and frustrating the insurance claims process can be—especially when liability comes into question. Recent experiences in New York State have highlighted this dilemma, particularly in a recent three-car collision involving dubious liability decisions.
The Accident Overview
In a recent incident, our protagonist, referred to here as Driver C, found themselves in the eye of a storm following a three-car accident. The crash involved Driver A, insured by Allstate, Driver B, covered by State Farm, and Driver C, with GEICO. To clarify the chain of events: Driver A ran a red light, prompting Driver B to collide with them. This resulted in Driver A spinning into the path of Driver C, causing damage to their vehicle. Thankfully, the event was captured on Driver C’s dash cam, providing important evidence of the sequence of events.
The Insurance Puzzle
After the accident, Driver C promptly contacted their insurance provider to discuss the next steps. The suggestion was to file a claim against Driver A’s insurance. Shortly afterward, Driver A’s insurer reached out for a statement. Despite presenting the compelling dash cam footage, Driver C received disappointing news: Allstate decided to assign 70% liability to Driver A and place 30% on Driver B. Their reasoning? Driver B, who had the green light, didn’t do enough to avoid the collision.
This partial blame on Driver B has placed Driver C in a difficult position. Despite not being at fault in any capacity, they are left with the daunting task of repairing their vehicle without having full coverage for the damages incurred.
The Dilemma: What Are the Options?
With the possibility of moving forward unclear, Driver C is seeking advice on the best course of action. They wonder whether they should:
-
File a Claim with Their Own Insurance: This would mean paying the deductible upfront while hoping that GEICO could later recover those costs from Allstate. However, there’s a genuine concern about potential premium increases, especially for a driver with a clean record.
-
Challenge the Liability Determination: Given that Driver A was clearly at fault for running the red light, it might seem reasonable for Driver C to push back against Allstate’s decision.
-
Explore Legal Options: If negotiations break down, seeking legal guidance may become necessary to ensure that
