What Are Your Options When a Rental Car Driver Causes an Accident and Has No Insurance Coverage?
Navigating the aftermath of a collision can be challenging, especially when the at-fault driver is uninsured or underinsured. Consider the following scenario: you’re involved in a crash caused entirely by a rental car driver, and despite clear evidence—including police reports and video footage—the individual’s insurance refuses to cover your damages.
In this case, the driver’s step-parent rented the vehicle, but they were not added to the insurance policy. Additionally, the driver was under 25, which can complicate coverage and liability issues. While your own insurance has covered most of your expenses, you still face out-of-pocket costs amounting to several thousand dollars, which the responsible party’s insurer refuses to reimburse.
Your insurer has indicated they won’t pursue legal action but will attempt to recover any amounts paid on your behalf. Meanwhile, the at-fault party has attempted to evade responsibility by leaving the scene, failing to exchange insurance information, and not reporting the accident to the rental company or their insurer. This evasive behavior makes collecting damages increasingly difficult.
So, what steps can you take if the liable party refuses to pay?
-
Consult with a legal professional: An experienced personal injury attorney can evaluate the specifics of your case and advise whether pursuing a lawsuit is a viable option. Legal action can sometimes compel the responsible party to pay damages, especially if they are intentionally acting to avoid responsibility.
-
Investigate all avenues of recovery: Beyond the at-fault driver, consider whether other parties might be liable—such as the rental company or the step-parent, particularly if improper rental or policy violations occurred.
-
Document everything: Maintain thorough records of all communications, evidence, and expenses related to the incident. Detailed documentation strengthens any legal claim or insurance recovery effort.
-
Explore other resources: In some cases, uninsured motorist coverage (if available through your policy) can help recover costs when the liable party is uninsured or uncooperative.
Bottom Line: When faced with an uninsured or uncooperative at-fault driver following a collision in a rental vehicle, consulting a legal expert is often the best course of action. They can assess whether pursuing legal action aligns with your circumstances and help you understand your rights and options for recovering losses. Remember, each situation is unique, and professional guidance is essential in navigating complex insurance and liability issues.
