Drunk driver totaled my car and now I’m up the river without a paddle

Title: Navigating the Fallout After a Drunk Driving Incident: What to Do When Your Car Is Totaled


Experiencing a car accident caused by a drunk driver can be overwhelming, especially when it results in the total loss of your vehicle. Recently, I found myself in this distressing situation and wanted to share my experience to help others who might face similar challenges.

It was a typical evening; I returned home from work and parked my car in front of my house, just as I always do. Within ten minutes, a driver under the influence of alcohol hit the back of my vehicle, causing significant damage to the entire rear end. Living in Minnesota, I rely heavily on my car, not only for daily commuting but also for my job—delivering wedding cakes.

The driver was promptly arrested, but since then, my ordeal has only intensified. The non-responsive nature of the at-fault driver’s insurance provider, The General, made communication difficult. Fortunately, my insurance company, State Farm, has been more cooperative. However, they informed me that their payout would only cover about 75% of my car’s current market value, leaving me approximately $4,000 short on my auto loan.

I was unfamiliar with gap insurance at the time of purchase, and unfortunately, it doesn’t seem to cover me now. It feels unjust to be financially burdened with the remaining debt for a vehicle I no longer own, particularly when the accident was caused by someone else’s reckless decision to drive drunk.

Currently, I’m facing the challenge of how to manage this unexpected financial shortfall. I can’t afford to replace my vehicle right now, and without reliable transportation, my ability to earn a living—delivering wedding cakes—is severely compromised.

If you’ve experienced a similar situation or have advice, I would greatly appreciate your guidance. Are there avenues I haven’t considered that could help alleviate this financial burden? Or am I entirely out of options?

Update: After some research and input from the community, I realize that my insurance is actually paying the actual cash value of my car. Interestingly, some of you asked whether factors like new tires influence the payout—it’s something I’m still trying to figure out.

Thank you all for your support and insights. Navigating the aftermath of such an incident is tough, but community advice makes it a little easier.


Disclaimer: This blog post is a personal account and should not replace professional legal or insurance advice. If you find yourself in a similar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *