Understanding Insurance Disputes When a Tree Falls: Wind and Rain Factors and How to Respond
Experiencing property damage due to falling trees can be stressful, especially when insurance claims are denied unexpectedly. Recently, a homeowner faced such a situation after a tree collapsed onto their shed. The key issue? The homeowner’s local arborist assessed that the tree fell due to a combination of wind and rain, while the insurance company contended that only rain was involved—leading to the claim being denied.
What’s Typically Covered?
Insurance policies often specify coverage for damage caused by certain perils, including wind, rain, and storms. However, the interpretation of what caused the tree to fall can significantly influence the outcome of a claim. When an arborist points out that both wind and rain contributed to the collapse, yet the insurer attributes it solely to rain, disputes like this may arise.
Why Do Insurance Companies Sometimes Deny Claims in These Situations?
Insurance providers review claims based on policy language and their assessments. If they determine the cause was primarily rain—perhaps because rain can weaken tree roots or soil stability—coverage might be denied, especially if wind wasn’t officially reported or documented. It’s important to review your policy details to understand what perils are covered.
Steps to Take When Facing a Denied Claim
-
Request a Detailed Explanation: Contact your insurance company for a written statement explaining the denial. Clarify the reasons and the evidence they considered.
-
Seek a Professional Assessment: Obtain an independent evaluation from a certified arborist or tree expert. Their report can provide authoritative insights about the cause of the fall.
-
Review Your Insurance Policy: Carefully examine the policy’s language regarding storm damage, wind, and rain. Determine whether the circumstances align with coverage parameters.
-
Appeal the Decision: Many insurers have an appeals process. Submit your independent expert’s report and any additional evidence to support your case.
-
Consult with a Specialist: If necessary, seek advice from an insurance claims attorney or a public adjuster who can assist in navigating the dispute and advocating on your behalf.
Preventive Measures for the Future
- Regularly inspect your trees for signs of weakness or disease.
- Maintain proper tree health through professional pruning and care.
- Be aware of local weather patterns and their potential impact.
Final Thoughts
Disputes with insurance companies over claim denials are common, especially in complex cases involving natural events. Staying informed
