Dealing with Insurance Disputes After a Fallen Tree: When Weather Claims Don’t Match Expert Opinions
When a tree unexpectedly crashes onto your property, the aftermath can be both stressful and confusing—especially if insurance claims get complicated. Recently, a property owner faced such a situation: a tree toppled onto their shed, and the explanation provided by an arborist differed from their insurer’s assessment, leading to a denial of coverage.
The Incident:
A mature tree fell onto a shed on a homeowner’s property. The damage was evident, but the reasons behind the fall became a point of contention. An certified local arborist evaluated the scene and concluded that the tree’s failure was caused by a combination of strong winds and rain—a common duo that can weaken tree structures.
Insurance Company’s Position:
However, when the homeowner filed a claim, their insurer responded differently. They insisted the tree only fell due to rain, a reason they considered insufficient for coverage, and ultimately denied the claim. Adding to the frustration, no representative from the insurance company ever inspected the property or the fallen tree in person.
Understanding the Discrepancy:
It’s not unusual for insurers to scrutinize claims involving natural events like storms or weather-related incidents. They often rely on official weather reports, their policies, and sometimes, their own assessments. However, expert opinions—such as those provided by certified arborists—can sometimes shed a different light on the actual causes of damage.
What Are Your Options?
If you find yourself in a similar situation, consider the following steps:
-
Gather Evidence:
Obtain detailed reports from certified arborists or tree specialists that clearly explain the cause of the fall. -
Review Your Policy:
Carefully read your insurance policy to understand what types of damage and causes are covered. -
Request a Re-evaluation:
Contact your insurer to request a formal reassessment, ideally involving an inspection by an independent or qualified adjuster. -
File an Appeal:
If a claim is denied, many insurers have formal appeals processes. Submit your evidence and request reconsideration. -
Seek Legal Advice:
If disputes persist, consulting a legal professional familiar with insurance claims can help you understand your rights and options. -
Consult Consumer Resources:
Contact local consumer protection agencies or insurance commissions for guidance and support.
Final Thoughts:
Insurance disputes over natural damages can be challenging, especially
