Title: Navigating Vehicle Damage Incidents in Private Driveways: Insurance and Liability Considerations
When two unattended vehicles unexpectedly collide in a private driveway, it raises important questions about liability, insurance coverage, and potential financial implications. Here, we explore a real-world scenario to understand how such incidents are typically handled, especially when involving family members or residents in the household.
Case Study: A Driveway Collision Between Two Vehicles
Imagine a homeowner living in Wayne County, Michigan, who experiences a minor collision in their driveway. The vehicles involved are a 2017 Ford Expedition, which is parked and fully insured with broad collision coverage, and a 20-year-old’s project truck—a 1974 Ford F100—that’s licensed and insured but currently undergoing restoration.
In this situation, the young man exits his truck after parking it uphill from the Expedition. As he closes the door, it inadvertently pops out of gear, causing the truck to roll backward and collide with the parked SUV. The incident is captured on security cameras, showing the young man outside the vehicle at the moment of impact.
Insurance Details and Damage Assessment
The homeowner’s Expedition has sustained notable damage: a flat tire, bumper and headlight damage, and potential harm to aftermarket wheels, tires, lift kits, and suspension components. Estimated repairs could exceed the insurance deductible of $1,000. Conversely, the project truck only has superficial scratches, with minimal cosmetic damage.
Liability and Responsibility: Who Pays?
The key question arises: Is the young man at fault since he was outside the vehicle at the moment it moved? Typically, liability depends on whether the driver was operating the vehicle appropriately and if proper precautions were followed. Even being outside the vehicle does not automatically absolve responsibility if the vehicle moved unexpectedly due to mechanical issues or failure to secure it.
Coverage Considerations
-
Auto Insurance: Since the truck was insured and parked, his insurance policy might cover damages if deemed at fault. This could include liability coverage if someone else was injured or property was damaged.
-
Homeowners Insurance: Usually, damages caused by vehicles are not covered under a standard homeowners policy unless specific endorsements are in place, which is uncommon.
-
Liability and Fault: Given the circumstances, it’s likely perceived as the truck’s operator’s fault, especially if negligence or failure to secure the vehicle is evident.
Financial Implications and Long-Term Concerns
From a financial standpoint, repair costs to the SUV may surpass the deductible, and insurance claims
