Understanding Insurance Disputes When a Tree Falls: Wind vs. Rain
Facing the aftermath of a fallen tree can be stressful, especially when insurance claims are involved. Recently, a homeowner experienced this firsthand when a tree collapsed onto their shed. The certified arborist attributed the fall to a combination of wind and rain, yet the insurance company contested this assessment, asserting that only rain was responsible and subsequently denied the claim. This situation highlights common challenges homeowners may face when navigating insurance disputes over fallen trees.
Why the Discrepancy? Wind and Rain Factors
Trees often fall due to multiple environmental factors. An arborist’s evaluation considers the physical causes, such as wind pressure or saturated soil from rainfall that weakens roots. In this case, the professional indicated that both wind and rain contributed to the tree’s failure. Insurance companies, however, may analyze claims differently, sometimes focusing solely on specific causes outlined in policy terms. This can lead to disagreements over coverage eligibility, especially if their assessment concludes that only natural elements like rain are involved, which may be excluded from coverage.
Is It Common for Insurers to Deny Claims Based on Cause?
Yes, insurance policies often specify coverage conditions related to weather-related damages. Some policies may exclude damage caused solely by certain elements or require specific conditions to be met for coverage to apply. It’s not unusual for insurers to verify the cause of damage through their assessments and deny claims if they believe the cause falls outside the covered scenarios.
What Are the Next Steps for Homeowners?
If you find yourself in a similar situation, here are some recommended actions:
-
Request a Detailed Explanation: Obtain a written report from the insurance company detailing why the claim was denied, including any evidence or reasoning used.
-
Gather Evidence: Collect all relevant documentation, such as pictures of the fallen tree, reports from certified arborists, weather data, and any other supporting information that clarifies the cause.
-
Seek a Second Opinion: Consider hiring your own independent arborist or expert to assess the cause of the tree’s fall. Their report can be valuable in contesting the insurer’s decision.
-
Review Policy Terms Carefully: Understand what is covered and under what conditions. This knowledge can inform your next steps and strengthen your case.
-
File an Appeal: Many insurance companies have an appeals process. Submit a formal appeal with supporting evidence to advocate for coverage.
-
Explore Legal Assistance: If disputes remain unresolved, consulting with an attorney experienced in insurance claims can help you understand your
