Optimizing Fertility Benefits with Dual Health Insurance Coverage: What You Need to Know
Navigating health insurance options for fertility treatments can be complex, especially when juggling coverage from multiple plans. Recently, a couple faced this challenge firsthand and sought advice on how to effectively utilize two insurance policies to maximize benefits while managing costs.
Understanding the Scenario
The couple currently benefits from the spouse’s employer-sponsored health insurance, which provides strong out-of-network coverage—covering approximately 70% after a modest $250 deductible. This plan has significantly eased the financial burden of weekly therapy sessions. However, its fertility benefits are limited, with a lifetime cap of $5,000 for IVF treatments—a cap they find inadequate given their plans to pursue more extensive fertility options.
Conversely, the husband’s employer offers a health plan that includes Progyny—a fertility benefits provider designed to cover IVF procedures, which they find highly appealing. The catch? This plan has a higher out-of-network deductible of $4,000 and relatively less comprehensive coverage for other health needs. The couple is contemplating maintaining both plans to leverage their respective advantages, especially since the wife’s insurance costs only $50 per month for joint coverage.
Key Consideration: How Does Coordination of Benefits Function?
The critical question pertains to how the two insurance policies coordinate when claims are filed. Typically, in dual coverage scenarios, one plan is designated as the primary payer, and the other as secondary. Usually, the primary plan is responsible for processing and paying claims first, with the secondary plan covering remaining eligible expenses.
In practice, this means:
- The primary insurance (likely the spouse’s current plan for her treatments) will process claims first.
- Once the primary coverage has paid its portion, the secondary insurance (the husband’s plan) can be billed for any remaining costs, including out-of-pocket expenses or co-insurance.
Benefits of Maintaining Dual Coverage
By keeping both insurance plans active, especially when one offers specialized fertility benefits, the couple can significantly reduce their out-of-pocket expenses. For example:
- Submission of claims to both insurers can maximize coverage for IVF and related treatments.
- The secondary plan might help cover therapy or other health expenses not fully addressed by the primary policy.
- The minimal monthly cost of the wife’s plan makes it a cost-effective way to bolster overall benefits.
Practical Steps
- Confirm plan details: Ensure you understand each plan’s coordination of benefits rules.
- Keep detailed records: Maintain all receipts, claim submissions, and communications.
3.
