Used points to rent a car, paid $5.47 on my credit card, now insurance won’t cover the damage. Am I screwed?

Understanding the Implications of Using Loyalty Points for Rental Car Coverage with Credit Card Insurance

Navigating rental car insurance can be complex, especially when loyalty points and discounts are involved. Recently, a traveler shared their experience of renting a vehicle through Enterprise, utilizing loyalty points to significantly reduce the rental cost. The final amount billed was a modest $5.47, fully paid with a Chase Sapphire Reserve (CSR) credit card, which is known for offering primary car rental coverage when the full rental amount is charged to the card and the collision damage waiver (CDW) is declined.

However, complications arose following a minor accident during the rental period. The individual filed a claim with CSR’s insurance provider, Virginia Surety/Assurant. Despite previous successful claims, this time, the insurer requested additional documentation — specifically, a billing statement showing the “full amount charged” for the rental. Although the individual submitted proof of the $5.47 charge, the insurer persisted in their request, raising concerns about whether the use of loyalty points might affect coverage eligibility.

Key Details to Consider:

  • The billed amount at the time of rental was $5.47, as confirmed on the credit card statement.
  • The rental was paid in full with the CSR credit card, satisfying the primary coverage criteria.
  • The renter declined the CDW offered by the rental company.
  • The terms and conditions of the Chase Sapphire Reserve specify that the full rental cost must be charged to the card, with no explicit mention of restrictions regarding discounts or the use of points.

Potential Issues:

The crux of the dispute seems to hinge on whether using loyalty points to reduce the rental’s cost negates the insurance coverage. The insurer appears to be disputing whether the amount of $5.47 truly reflects the “full” rental cost, a requirement for primary coverage under the CSR policy.

Legal and Practical Insights:

  • Insurance Policy Terms: Most credit card rental insurance policies stipulate that the full rental amount must be charged to the card. In this case, that condition was met, regardless of the final out-of-pocket expense.
  • Use of Loyalty Points or Discounts: Generally, credit card policies do not restrict coverage based on the use of points or discounts unless explicitly stated. The key requirement is that the total billed amount is charged to the card.
  • Documentation: The individual provided a clear statement showing the charge, which aligns with the policy requirements.

Advice for Similar Situations:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *