Understanding Insurance Challenges: When Multiple Claims Impact Home Coverage
Navigating the world of homeowners insurance can be complex, especially when past claims influence future coverage options. For homeowners with multiple properties, the situation can become even more nuanced. Here’s a real-world example highlighting some common concerns and questions around insurance claims and policy eligibility.
A Homeowner’s Experience with Multi-Property Insurance and Claim History
Recently, a homeowner faced difficulty securing a new insurance policy due to their history of claims. In August 2023, they replaced their roof after a hailstorm in Texas—a first and only claim in 15 years of residence at that property.
The homeowner had subsequently moved to Colorado, where they owned two homes simultaneously for around two and a half years. They rented out the Texas property, which was sold last year. The Colorado home, with a roof over 12 years old, was also damaged by hail recently, prompting a claim there as well.
Throughout these years, they have experienced increasing insurance premiums—rising from $3,000 to over $4,300 annually—leading them to explore new providers. Currently insured with Connect, the homeowner became aware that their insurer had transferred their policy to Homesite, and they began shopping for quotes. During their inquiry with State Farm, they were told the company was “cracking down” on clients with multiple claims within a short timeframe.
Key Questions for Homeowners with Multiple Properties and Claims
This situation raises several important questions that many homeowners might consider:
-
Does owning multiple properties with separate policies influence how insurance companies assess risk?
Property ownership often involves multiple policies—should insurers consider the combined risk profile of all properties, or are claims evaluated individually? -
Would contacting other insurers make a difference, or is this a standard policy stance across providers?
If one insurer declines coverage due to claim history, will others adopt similar policies, or are there alternatives? -
Could working with a private insurance agent provide better options?
Independent agents can sometimes navigate the nuances of multiple policies and claim histories more effectively than direct companies.
Final Thoughts
Insurance providers are continually adjusting their underwriting criteria, especially concerning recent claims. Homeowners with multiple properties and a history of claims may face increased scrutiny or coverage restrictions. However, exploring different insurers and consulting with specialized agents can offer pathways to suitable coverage options. If you find yourself in a similar situation, consider reaching out to independent agents who can advocate on your behalf and
