Understanding Diminished Value Claims in California: Is Selling Immediately After Repairs a Smart Strategy?
Navigating insurance claims after a vehicle accident can be complex, especially when it involves potential diminished value (DV). If you’ve recently been involved in an accident and are considering your options, here’s a comprehensive guide based on real-world scenarios to help you make informed decisions.
Case Overview: Rear-End Collision and Repair Costs
Imagine you own a 2022 Kia Niro PHEV, which was rear-ended, resulting in approximately $9,646 worth of structural damage to the rear body. Your insurance provider, Geico, is covering these repairs, which are expected to take about four weeks.
Your main considerations include: whether to file for a DV claim after repairs, the impact of selling the vehicle shortly thereafter, and how insurance companies typically handle such claims.
Can You Claim Diminished Value Before Selling Your Car?
Some vehicle owners wonder if it’s beneficial to sell their car immediately after repairs to maximize the payout from a diminished value claim. The crux of this question lies in the possibility of recovering the vehicle’s lost value due to the accident—especially if it has sustained structural or frame damage.
Testing the Market Value
Before deciding, it’s helpful to assess your car’s current market value. Using platforms like Carvana and CarMax, you can obtain instant offers both with and without indicating that the vehicle was involved in an accident.
For example:
-
Carvana offers approximately $20,000 if you do not disclose accident history, but the offer drops to around $16,400 if you include the vehicle’s past collision and repair costs.
-
CarMax presents an offer of $20,000 without accident disclosure, whereas declaring damage and structural concerns may reduce their offer to somewhere between $10,211 and $15,357.
Evaluating Damage and Structural Impact
A detailed repair estimate suggests that your vehicle has sustained structural frame damage. Notable signs include:
- Replacement of the rear body panel made of High Strength Steel (HSS), indicating structural repair.
- Repairs to the floor pan, quarter panels, and inner structural components.
Such damage noticeably affects the vehicle’s resale value due to the involvement of structural parts, not just cosmetic panels. While the damage may not render the vehicle a total loss, it’s essential to disclose these repairs when selling, and they can influence valuation.
Strategies for Diminished Value Claims
Given this background, there are several potential approaches:
1
