What Are Your Options When a Rental Car Accident Isn’t Covered by Insurance?
Accidents involving rental cars can sometimes become complex, especially when insurance coverage isn’t straightforward. If you’ve recently been involved in a collision where the at-fault driver was behind the wheel of a rental vehicle—and their insurance refuses to cover damages—you’re likely wondering what steps to take next.
The Scenario: A Rental Car Collision Without Insurance Coverage
Imagine this: You’re involved in an incident where another vehicle — a rental car — hits you. The police report and video footage clearly establish the other driver’s fault. However, here’s where things get complicated. The person operating the rental car isn’t directly on the insurance policy; instead, their step-father — who arranged the rental — didn’t add her to the insurance coverage. To make matters worse, she was under 25, which often brings additional insurance exclusions or restrictions.
Your own insurance provider stepped in to cover most of your damages, but you’re left covering a few thousand dollars out-of-pocket. Now, the rental company’s insurance is refusing to honor the claim, citing the driver’s lack of proper coverage.
Legal and Practical Considerations
Your insurance company has indicated they won’t pursue legal action against the at-fault party but will attempt to recover the expenses they’ve paid on your behalf. Unfortunately, the at-fault driver has shown reluctance to cooperate — leaving the scene without exchanging insurance information, ignoring your attempts to contact them, and failing to report the accident to their insurer or the rental agency. This evasive behavior raises concerns about the likelihood of recovering your expenses through traditional means.
Should You Consider Legal Action?
While it’s tempting to take the matter to court, legal action isn’t always the most straightforward solution. Filing a lawsuit can be time-consuming and costly, and success depends heavily on the defendant’s ability to pay and their willingness to cooperate. Given the circumstances — especially the evasive approach of the at-fault driver — pursuing legal recourse may or may not yield the desired outcome.
What Can You Do Next?
-
Consult a Legal Professional: An attorney specializing in personal injury and property damage can assess the specifics of your case and advise you on the viability of suing the at-fault driver.
-
Explore Small Claims Court: If the amount you’re seeking falls within the jurisdictional limits, this could be a quicker and less expensive pathway.
-
Gather All Evidence: Maintain detailed
