What Are Your Options After a Rental Car Accident with No Insurance Coverage?
Accidents can happen unexpectedly, especially when involving rental vehicles. If you find yourself in a situation where you’ve been hit by a rental car driver who isn’t covered by insurance, navigating the next steps can be challenging. Here’s a detailed overview of such a scenario, based on real-world cases, and guidance on how to proceed.
Understanding the Situation
Imagine being involved in an accident where the at-fault party was driving a rental vehicle. Police reports and video evidence confirm their fault. However, complications arise because the individual responsible was not listed on the insurance policy—perhaps their step-parent rented the car, did not add her to the policy, and she was underage at the time.
In this case, your own insurance has stepped in to cover most of your damages. Unfortunately, you’re still out a few thousand dollars due to uncovered expenses, and the rental company’s insurance refuses to accept liability. The at-fault driver’s insurance is either unavailable or unwilling to cover the damages.
Your Insurance Company’s Response
Typically, your insurance company will handle the claim by pursuing reimbursement or subrogation from the responsible party or their insurance if possible. In this scenario, your insurer has stated they do not intend to sue but will demand reimbursement for the damages they’ve paid out. Despite this, efforts by the responsible party to avoid responsibility—such as leaving the scene and not reporting the incident—may hinder recovery efforts.
Legal Considerations and Next Steps
Given these circumstances, you might be contemplating legal action against the responsible individual. Before proceeding, consider the following:
-
Assess the Evidence: Police reports and video evidence strengthen your case, but personal accounts and the responsible party’s response are also crucial.
-
Insurance Limitations: Since the at-fault driver’s insurance isn’t covering the damages—possibly due to lack of coverage, improper policy inclusion, or their refusal—they may not be a viable target for recovery.
-
Lawsuits and Enforcement: Filing a lawsuit is an option, but it’s important to understand the potential costs, the likelihood of recovery, and whether the responsible party has assets to cover judgment.
-
Consult a Legal Professional: Engaging an attorney experienced in personal injury and vehicle accident claims can help clarify your options, evaluate whether pursuing legal action is worthwhile, and assist in navigating the complexities of uninsured motorist claims.
Practical Advice
- Document Everything: Keep detailed
