Understanding Sewer Backup vs. Plumbing Issues
Recently, I experienced a sewage backup in my basement. Fortunately, I was there when the water began to rise through the floor drains and even the toilet. I quickly contacted the water department, and a technician arrived within 15 minutes. He confirmed there was a blockage in the main line but needed to call in a specialist with the necessary equipment to clear it. It took about 45 minutes to an hour from my call to when they resolved the issue, during which time my basement accumulated about 4-6 inches of black sewage water. Once the water receded, I was left with a thick layer of black sludge covering the entire floor.
I filed a claim with my insurance provider (Progressive/Homesite), and fortunately, I have a sewage backup endorsement with a $10,000 limit. I was initially concerned since the damages far exceed that amount, but the adjuster classified the incident as a plumbing issue, which falls under my standard policy, allowing my full dwelling and personal property limits to apply.
The technician from the water department also provided information on how to file a claim with the township’s insurance. I submitted that claim, and they finally reached out to me a month later. So far, my insurance has covered about $30,000, and I expect the total to reach between $40,000 and $50,000 by the time everything is settled.
I have two questions:
-
Why did my insurance classify this as a plumbing issue when it appears to be a clear case of sewage backup?
-
If I involve the township’s insurance, is there a possibility that my insurance could later reclassify it as a sewer backup and seek reimbursement?
I assume that if the latter occurs, the township’s insurance would reimburse my insurer. However, from the documents I received, it seems they only cover personal property damage and not any damage to the dwelling itself.
Currently, I’m considering leaving the township’s insurance out of this and allowing my insurance to handle the entire cost, despite the potential for higher rates afterward.
Additionally, it’s worth mentioning that five other homes also experienced the sewer backup, so this issue wasn’t limited to just my property. I conveyed to my insurance that the blockage was in the township’s main line, indicating their responsibility in this matter.
Thanks for your insights!
It sounds like you’ve been through a really tough situation, but it’s great to hear that you were able to act quickly and get help. Here are some insights into your questions:
Insurance Classification: The classification of your incident as a plumbing issue rather than a sewer backup could be due to various factors. Insurance companies often have specific guidelines for categorizing claims, and if they determined that the cause of the water damage was ultimately due to a blockage in the main line—something they viewed as a plumbing problem—it might have influenced their decision. This could also be due to the initial response from the water department, which highlighted a blockage in their system rather than a failure of your home’s plumbing specifically. It may be worth reaching out to your insurance adjuster for clarification on their reasoning, as understanding their classification might help you in future claims.
Involving the Township’s Insurance: If you go through the township’s insurance and they do reimburse your insurance company, it might trigger a review of your claim by your insurer. There’s a possibility they could reclassify the situation as a sewer backup if new information came to light or if there was a shift in the understanding of the event’s cause. However, in many cases, once a claim has been paid, it’s unlikely for insurers to retroactively change their decisions unless there’s clear evidence of an error. It’s important to be transparent with both your insurance and the township about the situation to avoid complications.
Given that other homeowners were also affected and it was a broader issue, it’s likely that there will be discussions about liability and coverage, which could impact your situation positively.
If you’re considering not involving the township’s insurance, weighing the long-term implications of potentially raising your rates against the immediate convenience of having your insurance cover everything is wise. However, keep in mind that if the township’s insurance covers some of the costs, it could help mitigate future rate increases.
Overall, engaging with your insurance agent for guidance and possibly consulting with a lawyer experienced in insurance claims could provide you with more tailored advice suited to your particular situation. Good luck, and I hope things get resolved swiftly for you!