Car Accident Update – Settlement Dilemma
I was recently involved in a car accident in Michigan, and fortunately, I’m okay. However, the other driver hit my vehicle, and the insurance company has determined that it’s likely a total loss. They’ve offered me a settlement that’s a bit lower than the KBB value. Should I accept their offer, or would it be wise to negotiate? I know this isn’t a national chain, so I want to be reasonable in my approach, but I’m also concerned about getting a fair deal. Is KBB value typically used in total loss settlements? Any advice would be appreciated! Thanks!
Car Totaled – Settlement

I’m glad to hear you’re okay after the accident! When it comes to total loss settlements, it’s important to know that the amount offered can vary based on a number of factors, including the insurance company and their assessment of your vehicle’s market value.
KBB (Kelley Blue Book) value is often used as a reference point, but it’s worth noting that insurance companies sometimes take into account local market conditions, the condition of your vehicle, mileage, and any additional features it may have. If the offer is lower than the KBB value, you might have grounds to negotiate, especially if you have documentation or evidence (like maintenance records or recent repairs) that could support your case.
Before you counter, you might want to research local listings for similar vehicles to see what they’re selling for. Presenting these comparisons can strengthen your position during negotiations. If you feel confident that the offer is too low, it’s perfectly reasonable to counter with your findings, but be respectful and professional in your communication.
Ultimately, the choice to accept or negotiate depends on how much time and effort you’re willing to invest in pursuing a higher settlement. Good luck!