Why am I getting strange quotes from Progressive? I’ve been experimenting with their insurance quotes and noticed that insuring a Toyota RAV4 or Venza is actually more expensive than insuring a Lexus NX. How does that make sense? Shouldn’t Toyota vehicles be cheaper to insure?
Why is Progressive giving me weird quotes?

There can be several reasons why you’re seeing higher insurance quotes for a Toyota RAV4 or Venza compared to a Lexus NX, despite Toyota generally being viewed as a more affordable brand. Here are some factors that might be at play:
Safety Ratings and Features: Insurance companies often consider safety ratings and features when determining premiums. If the Lexus NX has more advanced safety features or better crash test ratings compared to the Toyota models, it could lead to lower premiums.
Repair Costs: Lexus vehicles, while generally more expensive to repair, can sometimes have lower rates due to the availability of parts or their durability. Conversely, if the Toyota models are considered to have higher repair costs or more claims associated with them, this can influence quotes.
Theft Rates: Some vehicles are more likely to be stolen than others, which can impact insurance rates. If the RAV4 or Venza have higher theft rates, that could contribute to the higher quotes.
Driver Demographics: Insurance companies also look at the demographics of typical drivers for certain models. If RAV4 or Venza drivers have a higher incidence of accidents or claims, that could raise the rates.
Market Factors: Insurance quotes can fluctuate based on market conditions, risks, or underwriting guidelines that may specifically affect certain models or brands differently.
Coverage Limits and Discounts: Ensure you’re comparing the same coverage limits and discounts across the quotes. Sometimes discrepancies arise simply from differences in the policy details.
If you’re still unsure, it might be helpful to reach out to Progressive for clarification on their pricing model or to explore different coverage options.